Cushion or Control?

Updated: Oct 2

Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX vs. Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid GTX:
A boot can feel comfortable on a shop floor and very different halfway down a rocky descent. For this comparison, the useful question is how much cushioning you want between your feet and the trail, and how firmly you like a boot to hold its shape.
The Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX is my starting recommendation for hikers who prefer a more cushioned ride. The Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid GTX makes more sense if support matters more than softness. These recommendations draw on published testing and product specifications, rather than personal field testing.
What separates them
Priority | Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX | Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid GTX |
Underfoot feel | More cushioning in the cited laboratory tests | Firmer, less shock absorbing |
Main appeal | Comfortable movement on everyday hikes | Support without a traditional heavy boot feel |
Fit consideration | Standard fit is not especially broad | Medium-width fit; wide option also exists |
RunRepeat tested both exact mid-height models. Its Merrell results support a balance of cushioning and underfoot control, while its Salomon review emphasizes stability and grip but flags limited cushioning. Those findings are more useful than assuming every waterproof mid boot feels roughly the same. Merrell testing, Salomon testing.
Why choose the Merrell?
The Moab Speed 2 combines a FloatPro foam midsole with a FlexPlate and Vibram TC5+ outsole. That makes it a sensible candidate for someone who wants a hiking boot with a less cumbersome feel, while retaining structure underneath. It is a different model from the conventional Moab 3, so reviews of that boot should not decide this purchase. Product details.
The catch is fit. RunRepeat found the standard version restrictive for genuinely wide feet. I would not order it simply because another Merrell fit well. Try the actual size and width with the socks you plan to hike in, then use a downhill ramp to check toe clearance.
Why choose the Salomon?
The X Ultra 5 Mid is the stronger candidate for hikers who enjoy a firm platform. RunRepeat found that it delivers substantial support at a moderate weight, but that same firmness can disappoint someone expecting a plush walking shoe.
For a route with repeated rocky sections, I would put it on the fitting shortlist. For long days on hard, relatively smooth paths, I would start by comparing its comfort directly with the Merrell. That is a buying judgment based on the documented ride differences, not a claim that one outsole wins on every surface.
My buying recommendation
Choose the Merrell if cushioning is the missing ingredient in your current boots. Choose the Salomon if your priority is a supportive feel. Let heel hold and toe room make the final decision; a favorable review cannot compensate for the wrong fit.
Check options: Merrell men's · Merrell women's · Salomon men's · Salomon women's.
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through links in this article.





Comments