Room at Camp or Less Weight on the Trail?

Updated: Oct 6

Marmot Limelight 3 vs. Big Agnes Copper Spur UL3:
Three-person tents are often worth considering for two campers who want some breathing room. Add a dog, and the shape of the floor matters at least as much as the capacity printed on the bag.
I would shortlist the Limelight for shorter carries and the Copper Spur UL3 for trips where carrying weight matters more. This comparison uses the specific Limelight listing in the product sheet and published testing of the newer Copper Spur UL3.
The weight difference has a purpose
REI lists the Limelight 3 with 45.2 square feet of floor area, two doors, two vestibules, and an included footprint. Its packaged weight is 7 pounds 1.9 ounces. The pre-bent pole structure aims to create more upright walls and useful interior room. Limelight 3 specifications.
GearLab measured the reviewed Copper Spur UL3 at about 3.8 pounds packaged and praised its space relative to weight. Its review also makes the important tradeoff clear: lightweight fabric deserves more careful treatment than heavier tent material. Copper Spur UL3 field test.
These figures come from different sources, so they are not an independently repeated side-by-side measurement. Even so, the difference is large enough to matter when choosing the kind of tent you want to carry.
Priority | Better starting point |
Short walk from the car | Limelight 3 |
Longer backpacking days | Copper Spur UL3 |
Footprint included in the package | Limelight 3 |
Minimum bulk for the available space | Copper Spur UL3 |
What camping with a dog changes
Before buying, lay out your sleeping pads and the dog's bed using the tent's floor dimensions. A nominal three-person rating does not promise room for two wide pads and a sprawled large dog. Tapered floors and the placement of doors can make the same stated floor area feel different.
I would also think about the dog's behavior. A dog that settles immediately makes different demands on a tent from one that circles, paws at bedding, or presses against mesh. Neither tent should be treated as claw-proof.
An included footprint protects underneath the Limelight, but does not protect the inside floor from a dog's nails. Plan the sleeping arrangement accordingly.
Which one earns the place in your kit?
The Limelight makes sense if carrying an extra few pounds is a modest inconvenience on your usual trips. The Copper Spur makes a stronger case as walking distances grow and packed space becomes more valuable.
I would spend the extra money on the Copper Spur for regular backpacking. For mostly campsite-based weekends and occasional short walk-ins, I would start with the Limelight and put the savings toward a comfortable sleeping system.
Check options: Marmot Limelight 3 · Big Agnes Copper Spur UL3.
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through links in this article.





Comments